|   How we measure results:
 In
                                        order to measure the
                                        impact of the Critical-
                                        Thinking / Integral
                                        Education Program
                                        (CT-IED), we collect data
                                        at three different
                                        levels; student,
                                        classroom and staff. In
                                        order to set context it
                                        is good to know that most
                                        of our students live in
                                        resource-poor
                                        environments. Many lack
                                        access to adequate food,
                                        electricity, and running
                                        water and their
                                        ramshackle homes,
                                        commonly of dirt floors,
                                        tin walls and roofs, are
                                        located in dangerous
                                        slums which are adversely
                                        affected by earthquakes,
                                        mudslides and gang
                                        activity. Physical,
                                        emotional and
                                        psychological abuse is
                                        common.
 Students: We
                                        track the extent to which
                                        students are connected
                                        with and actively
                                        engaging in the CT-IED
                                        Program and our other
                                        programs and the extent
                                        to which those services
                                        result in improved
                                        functioning for the
                                        students served.
                                        Accordingly, we use
                                        various measures of;
 
 1.  The grades the
                                        students receive from
                                        their public school and
                                        college education.
 2.  The grades the
                                        students receive from our
                                        own CT-IED exams (3-4
                                        annually).
 3.  Their attendance
                                        and attentiveness.
 4.  The
                                        students depth of
                                        response to weekly
                                        homework assignments.
 5.   The
                                        students depth of
                                        response to impromptu
                                        in-class assignments.
 6.  Their
                                        interactions with other
                                        students and willingness
                                        to refer their
                                        friends/siblings.
 7.  The
                                        increase/decrease of
                                        personal problems issues
                                        at home, school, or with
                                        peers.
 8.  The depth of
                                        questions during our
                                        Wisdom Speaker events.
 9.  The
                                        students
                                        willingness to share
                                        their dreams/lucid dream
                                        and other state
                                        experiences.
 10. The emergence
                                        of nation-centric and
                                        world-centric
                                        perspectives.
 Explanation
                                        for 1, 2 and 3: Our
                                        pre 9th grade students
                                        begin attending this
                                        program at age 13. Many
                                        of our students are also
                                        in our sponsorship
                                        program. This means that
                                        we have found a sponsor
                                        for them who funds their
                                        education pre and post
                                        9th grade. If a teen has
                                        a sponsor they are
                                        mandated to attend CT-IED
                                        program. However, about
                                        20% of the CT-IED
                                        students are currently
                                        not sponsored and attend
                                        voluntarily.
 As part of maintaining
                                        their sponsorship the
                                        student must present a
                                        copy of their quarterly
                                        grades from the public
                                        school or college they
                                        attend. We require a
                                        grade point average of
                                        70%. This allows us to
                                        track their overall
                                        progress and we do see an
                                        overall trend of
                                        improvement, especially
                                        with the most interested
                                        CT-IED students.
                                        Non-sponsored students
                                        are not required to give
                                        us their grades.
 In the
                                        CT-IED program we have
                                        3-4 written exams each
                                        year. Some questions are
                                        one line responses,
                                        others are open ended. We
                                        are looking to see their
                                        ability to reply
                                        succinctly when required
                                        and also the depth of
                                        their responses. With the
                                        essay questions we are
                                        also seeking to measure
                                        the impact of our work
                                        when student connect
                                        topics and threads that
                                        we did not necessarily
                                        connect in the class.
 For instance, Jeff
                                        Carreira gave a video
                                        skype class on emptiness.
                                        The previous semester we
                                        were covering values
                                        hierarchies. We noticed
                                        in a later exam that one
                                        student was pondering the
                                        relationship between our
                                        values, and our ability
                                        to arrange them, to the
                                        fact that awareness
                                        arises from no-thing. 
                                        The exams also allow us
                                        to see the general stage
                                        of reference of the
                                        student, if traditional
                                        mythic, self-power or
                                        higher.
 We perform
                                        standard tracking of
                                        attendance, prior
                                        notification that a class
                                        will be missed and
                                        general overall
                                        attentiveness of each of
                                        the students. In our
                                        program there is a
                                        three-strikes-youre-out
                                        policy. We are seeking
                                        consistency in attendance
                                        and attentiveness as a
                                        mark of the impact of
                                        this work on the
                                        awareness of the
                                        individual.   Explanation
                                        for 4, 5, 6, and 7: We
                                        currently teach the
                                        CT-IED program once per
                                        week. We give homework
                                        each week which the
                                        student is asked to
                                        experiment with the class
                                        content and then present
                                        their findings the
                                        following week. This
                                        greatly encourages
                                        self-confidence and
                                        self-esteem (as we have
                                        seen even in the most
                                        meek students) because
                                        they have to present in
                                        front of their class
                                        mates.
 We also
                                        assign homework and
                                        impromptu in-class tasks
                                        to pairs of students and
                                        they again have to play
                                        out their experiments in
                                        class or the following
                                        week. When we randomly
                                        assign exercises during
                                        the class period, which
                                        the students have to
                                        quickly prepare for, then
                                        we mix and match them
                                        according to where they
                                        live. Guatemalans are
                                        still quite tribal and
                                        even kids who live a few
                                        miles apart have little
                                        to share with each other
                                        so this gives us a great
                                        opportunity to see how
                                        this work is positively
                                        impacting their ability
                                        to bond and produce a
                                        mutually agreeable
                                        response with a person
                                        who ordinarily would be
                                        avoided.
 We used to
                                        source new students by
                                        visiting other NGOs
                                        and informing them of our
                                        work and that besides the
                                        benefit of the CT-IED
                                        work, that there was the possibility
                                        that if a student
                                        attended they might also
                                        find a sponsor (we
                                        currently have 60
                                        children and adolescent
                                        with individual
                                        sponsors). We no longer
                                        do this and instead rely
                                        on and gauge the impact
                                        of the program by the
                                        number of new students
                                        referred to us by
                                        existing ones. Currently
                                        20% of our students at
                                        the end of 2013 are
                                        siblings, friends, or
                                        school mates who were
                                        referred to us by
                                        existing students. When
                                        we ask a newly referred
                                        student to introduce
                                        him/herself to the class
                                        we also ask what they
                                        heard that made them want
                                        to come; most often we
                                        hear that the classes
                                        have positively impacted
                                        the life,
                                        decision-making, and
                                        self-perspective of the
                                        referrer. This we really
                                        like to hear!   The
                                        students use this class
                                        to share personal issues
                                        in the context of the
                                        teachings which affords
                                        us the opportunity to
                                        address common teen
                                        problems in an open
                                        forum. They also approach
                                        us, the teachers, and our
                                        staff members before and
                                        after the class. We track
                                        the increase/decrease of
                                        personal problems, issues
                                        at home, with their
                                        boy/girl friends, at
                                        school, and with their
                                        peers which are reported
                                        during these meetings as
                                        a way to gauge the impact
                                        of the work. We also ask
                                        them to apply what they
                                        have learned to specific
                                        problems, and given
                                        permission, ask them to
                                        recount those newly
                                        emergent solutions with
                                        the class.    An
                                        additional method we use
                                        to seek feedback on the
                                        impact of the program is
                                        that during meal times
                                        (in this program) we
                                        assign seating based on
                                        their location, similar
                                        to how we mix and match
                                        the students from
                                        different villages and
                                        towns above. This gives
                                        us another indicator of
                                        positive impact of the
                                        work on the kids
                                        ability to make light
                                        conversation with peers
                                        from different
                                        geographical locations.   Explanation
                                        for 8, 9, and 10: In
                                        our Wisdom Speaker Series
                                        we invite guest speakers
                                        to give a seminar to our
                                        students, either
                                        in-person or via
                                        video-skype. As a measure
                                        of the impact of this
                                        program we monitor the
                                        number and the quality of
                                        questions that the
                                        students have for our
                                        invited guests. In the
                                        following weeks
                                        class we debrief and
                                        unpack the speaker event
                                        and are constantly
                                        seeking out gems of
                                        understanding that have
                                        solidified because of our
                                        course work and the
                                        content of the
                                        speakers event.   We seek
                                        clarity in our
                                        students recounting
                                        of dreams and lucid
                                        dreams, in the context of
                                        shadow or simple
                                        experimentation. We also
                                        gauge the impact of the
                                        work as positive since on
                                        several occasions we have
                                        had students who have
                                        experienced states of
                                        euphoria or great sadness
                                        and both simultaneously
                                        because of realizations
                                        during the classes. We
                                        allow and support these
                                        expressions and encourage
                                        the students to describe,
                                        as best they can, their
                                        experiences for the
                                        benefit of all the
                                        students.   One of the
                                        key areas by which we can
                                        measure the impact of our
                                        work is in the evidence
                                        for shifts in
                                        perspectives. In 2013 we
                                        challenged our students
                                        to write a one-page
                                        article titled My
                                        Perfect Day and
                                        then to share that with
                                        the class the following
                                        week. Many, as you can
                                        expect where egocentric,
                                        personal experience based
                                        narratives. However, two
                                        of our student revealed
                                        to us by means of their
                                        story that their
                                        perspective had shifted
                                        quite dramatically. Here
                                        is a summary of their
                                        stories;
 [Name removed] who is 21,
                                        a 3rd year student of
                                        ours, who is also being
                                        sponsored by one of our
                                        donors to study for a
                                        career as a chef. As part
                                        of his practical work his
                                        class was invited to
                                        select an impoverished
                                        village to cook for and
                                        feed for a day. The
                                        village they selected was
                                        only reachable by
                                        horseback. [Name removed]
                                        described this experience
                                        of helping other people
                                        as blissful
                                        and incorporated not only
                                        such an event as part of
                                        a homework exercise
                                        called My Perfect
                                        Day but also the
                                        fact that he saw himself
                                        with a worldwide chain of
                                        self-sustaining and free
                                        restaurants for the poor.
 [Name
                                        removed], 16, is a first
                                        year student who was
                                        referred to our work from
                                        another school after she
                                        expressed an interest in
                                        learning about
                                        philosophy. Also as part
                                        of our homework exercise
                                        called My Perfect
                                        Day, [Name
                                        removed], who wishes to
                                        study to be a nurse,
                                        expressed a wish to open
                                        medical clinic for the
                                        impoverished throughout
                                        the world.
 Please contact
                                        us if you are
                                        interested in investing
                                        in our programs.
 
   
 
 |